Charles Beard Economic Interpretation Constitution Thesis

Charles Beard Economic Interpretation Constitution Thesis-59
Probably all of these forces were in effect to one degree or another.Beard himself is quoted by Richard Hofstadter as saying in 1934 that "[r]are indeed is the savant who does not appear to be at war with himself in his own breast" and in 1940 that "Olympian certitude has exploded" (Hofstadter, 285).

Tags: 8th Essay Grade Lesson PlanProcess Essay How To Lose Weight Without Losing Your MindA Family Quarrel EssayOrwell Essay On Making TeaResearch Proposal TimelineAnarchist EssaysCollege Research Paper IdeasO Brother Where Art Thou And The Odyssey Comparison EssayHomework ExcuseResearch Paper On Human Trafficking

Professors in the constitutional law academy are the most intent on seeing that Beard stay buried.

They seem to fear that if Beard came back to life the Constitution would become a bastard anti-democratic document, lose its political legitimacy, and their enterprise of liberal versus conservative debate over the real meanings of the document would go into bankruptcy.

He further asserted that the Constitution was an economic document designed by those with money and property to protect those with money and property.

This class-struggle view was applied by Beard to all of American history.

Had he been cauterized by the barbarism of twentieth-century global war?

Or had he merely begun to be more tolerant, as so often happens as people reach the ends of their lives?

He instead sided with Hamilton and his elite capitalistic allies in the Federalist tradition.

In effect Beard belonged to the neo-Hamiltonian camp in the Progressive movement which Merrill Peterson identified as congregating around and championing the “bold use of the powers of the national government for constructive purposes.” In the wake of his disillusionment with American involvement in World War I, Beard’s viewpoint shifted toward an embrace of Jefferson’s general democratic image.

Moreover, the breakup of large Tory estates was discussed (Beard 1944, 119).

But it is the chapter on the Constitution that stands out.

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments Charles Beard Economic Interpretation Constitution Thesis

  • An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United.
    Reply

    An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States. Front Cover. Charles Austin Beard. Macmillan, 1921. Beard carries his thesis that the US Constitution did not originate out of high-minded, disinterested. Read full review.…

  • Charles Beard - Conservapedia Constitution
    Reply

    Beard in An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States 1913 and An Economic Interpretation of Jeffersonian Democracy 1915 extended Becker's thesis down to 1800 in terms of class conflict. To Beard, the Constitution was a counter-revolution, set up by rich bond.…

  • Beard An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the.
    Reply

    Buy "An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution" by Charles A. Beard 1874 - 1948. Beard claimed otherwise, and several times insisted that his thesis was.…

  • Charles beard's interpretation of the constitution -
    Reply

    In 1913, Beard published his most influential book, An Economic Interpretation of the U. S. formulating this interpretation, Beard drew from the scholarship of another famous historian named Carl L. Becker. Becker had argued the American Revolution really consisted of two.…

  • The Interpretation of Constitutional History, or
    Reply

    In An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States, published in 1913, Charles A. Beard arguedA century after the publication of An Economic Interpretation, one can fairly conclude both that the book was "seminal" and that subsequent scholarship has "undermined Beard's thesis."…

  • The Beard Thesis and the Seinfeld Defense Law &
    Reply

    In this, its centennial year, Charles Beard’s 1913 An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States retains its hold on both theBut it may be time for those who respect the Framers to acknowledge at least one deep vein of truth in Beard’s thesis and reply with an even deeper one.…

  • Charles Beard and the constitution a crit. analysis of "An
    Reply

    Charles Beard and the constitution a crit. analysis of "An economic interpretation of the constitution."…

  • The Founders, the Constitution, and the Historians.
    Reply

    How could Charles Beard have erred so badly in arguing that the Constitution. Founders was Charles Beard in An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution. Beard's thesis, seemingly well researched, was presented in a.…

  • Beard-Economic Interpretation of US Constitution
    Reply

    This is Charles A. Beard's highly controversial book An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of The United States 1965 whichBeard's original thesis from 1913 remains that the forming of the US Constitution was an effort by the economic well-to-do of the newly formed American social class.…

  • An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the
    Reply

    The Constitution, Beard argued, was designed to reverse the radical democratic tendencies^ Robert Livingston Schuyler, "Forrest McDonald's Critique of the Beard Thesis," Journal of SouthernEllen Nore, "Charles A. Beard's Economic Interpretation of the Origins of the Constitution," This.…

The Latest from new-history.ru ©